November 10, 2026
A $2.3 million settlement between the California Attorney General and Aspen Dental Management, Inc. is drawing significant attention across the dental support organization industry. The agreement, which still awaits court approval, carries implications that reach well beyond one company. Dykema's detailed analysis of the settlement, authored by Zachary Q. Hoard, Dean Gould, Jena E. Taft, and David Ko, identifies the core allegations and breaks down the terms that DSOs operating in California, and potentially other states, should understand.
The Allegations at the Heart of the Case
The California Attorney General brought two categories of claims against Aspen Dental Management. The first centered on California's prohibition against the corporate practice of dentistry. Regulators alleged that Aspen unlawfully interfered with and controlled the clinical operations of its contractually affiliated practices, including by offering direct payments to clinical employees to encourage the sale of products and services.
The second category involved advertising practices. Specific allegations included:
- Deceptive language in patient testimonials
- Vague or inexact pricing representations
- Failure to disclose conditions that could affect pricing or the scope of services
- Misleading statements about which insurance programs affiliated practices accepted
Settlement Terms: Penalties, Restitution, and an Unprecedented Injunction
Aspen agreed to pay $2 million in civil penalties and $300,000 in restitution. Beyond the financial terms, Dykema describes the injunctive provisions as unprecedented in scope for a DSO settlement. Those provisions impose a broad set of prohibitions and affirmative obligations on Aspen's California operations.
Operational Prohibitions
Under the injunction, Aspen is barred from a range of conduct that regulators viewed as crossing into clinical control or unfair business practice. Among the restrictions:
- Requiring departing practice owners to surrender offices or equipment; owners may assume leases and purchase equipment at fair market value
- Owning real property used by any affiliated practice
- Including noncompete provisions with licensed clinicians, or using overly restrictive non-solicitation clauses
- Tying service fees to practice revenue, sales, or profits
- Restricting practices from choosing their own product or laboratory vendors
- Directing or encouraging any licensed clinician (other than a practice owner) to sell services or increase revenue
- Compensating its own employees based on practice sales or revenue
- Allowing practice employees to receive incentive pay tied to sales, revenue, or profits
- Determining the salary, compensation, or work schedules of clinical staff
- Prohibiting or requiring practices to accept specific insurance plans
Required Compliance Procedures
Aspen must also implement affirmative internal procedures in California, including:
- Annual written renegotiation of service fees with each practice owner
- A written fee schedule for all products and laboratory services
- Registration with the California Dental Board as a Dental Group Advertising and Referral Service
- Quarterly written preapproval from practice owners for marketing campaigns, promotions, and discounts
Advertising Standards
On advertising, Aspen agreed to identify the practice owner's name in all advertisements, use only exact pricing without phrases such as "starting at" or "as low as," fully disclose conditions attached to any advertised free services, and ensure testimonials come from actual patients with appropriate disclosures when sourced from a different practice location.
What DSOs Should Take From This
Dykema's analysis notes that the settlement does not threaten the fundamental viability of the DSO model. However, the breadth and specificity of the injunctive terms confirm that state regulators are prepared to scrutinize the operational details of DSO-practice relationships closely. The analysis recommends that DSOs and affiliated practices review their contractual arrangements and operational protocols for compliance with state corporate practice of dentistry laws and advertising regulations, and consult legal counsel where questions arise.
Adapted from Aspen Dental Management, Inc. Settles California Corporate Practice of Dentistry Enforcement Action for $2 Million, originally published by Dykema on May 13, 2026.
Related professionals: Zachary Q. Hoard, Dean Gould, Jena E. Taft, David Ko.